In my previous blog, I introduced emotional literacy and self-regulation as life skills we were never formally taught yet are expected to master as leaders.

Leadership isn’t revealed in calm, predictable moments. It’s revealed when plans shift, deadlines slip, or conversations become heated. It’s in the unexpected turn, the public challenge, the rising tension that our capability, or lack of it, becomes visible.

That is where leadership either deepens trust or quietly erodes it in ways we don’t immediately see.

Every Leader Leaves an Emotional Wake

Imagine a boat moving through water. Long after it passes, waves continue to ripple outward. Leadership works the same way.

• Your tone in a tense meeting. 
• Your expression when someone pushes back. 
• Your reaction when performance slips.

Even if the moment feels small to you, it lingers with your team, and that lingering effect is your emotional wake.

Leaders often lack awareness that this is happening or underestimate the impact that their reactions have on others. What feels like “just being direct” can create hesitation. What feels like urgency can create anxiety. What feels like efficiency can shut down dialogue.

Self-regulation isn’t about suppressing emotion. It’s about recognizing that your reactions shape culture.

Why Capable Leaders Still React

Most leaders are intelligent, capable, and results driven. Yet under pressure, even seasoned professionals can default to behaviors that undermine their intent:

• Sharpening their tone
• Interrupting
• Over-directing
• Withdrawing
• Justifying instead of listening

This isn’t a character flaw, it’s biology. 

Under stress, the brain activates the threat response system — commonly known as fight, flight, or freeze. When that happens, cognitive clarity narrows and defensiveness rises. Listening decreases, urgency increases and the nervous system prioritizes protection over perspective.

What follows isn’t the emotion itself, it’s the automatic, unfiltered behavior that comes next and that behavior is what shapes culture.

The Patterns Leaders Don’t Always Notice

In my work with leaders, I often see consistent patterns emerge when pressure builds.

Some sharpen their tone, conversations accelerate, and urgency takes over. Others pull back, dialogue shortens and issues linger longer than they should. And some respond by giving more direction, delegating less, and increasing oversight to regain certainty.

Their underlying intention is to help or regain control, but the impact often feels like pressure, withdrawal, or distrust.

Be Proactive Through Preparation 

Most conversations about self-regulation focus on what to do after emotions rise. Strong leadership starts before that.

Be intentional about the conversations you walk into, especially the ones you know may be difficult.

Before the meeting begins, ask yourself:

• What typically triggers me in situations like this?
• What expectation of mine might be challenged?
• How do I want to show up, regardless of how it unfolds?

If missed deadlines consistently frustrate you, decide in advance how you will address them. If resistance tends to irritate you, commit to asking one clarifying question before offering direction.

Preparation doesn’t eliminate tension, it prevents reaction. Intentional leaders prepare themselves, not just their agenda.

Managing Your Internal Narrative

Emotions rise quickly and they intensify when fueled by interpretation or assumptions.

Under stress, we don’t just react to events, we react to the story we tell ourselves about them.  That internal narrative often sounds like:

• “They don’t respect me.”
• “This always happens.”
• “I have to fix this myself.”

Those stories may feel true in the moment, but they are often driven more by assumption than fact. 

Self-regulation requires the discipline to examine your narrative before acting on it.

Ask yourself:

• What facts do I have?
• What assumption am I making?
• Is the story I’m telling myself accurate?
• What else could be true?

Leaders who challenge their internal narrative prevent small triggers from becoming defining moments.

Let’s take this discussion one step further. The internal narrative isn’t only about others, it’s also about ourselves.

Apply the same discipline when negative self-talk surfaces and the internal critic questions your competence or capability:

• Is this true?
• Is this helpful?
• Is this moving me forward?

If not, you are responding to a constructed narrative vs. reality.

The key insight here is that intentional leaders manage the story before the story manages them.

Examples of Self-Regulation in Practice

Reactive:
“You always drop the ball.”

Regulated:
“I’m seeing a pattern. Let’s unpack what’s getting in the way.”

Reactive:
“This shouldn’t be this hard.”

Regulated:
“What obstacles are getting in the way?”

The difference isn’t softness, it’s intentionality. 

Why This Matters for Performance

Emotional reactivity quietly erodes:

• Psychological safety
• Honest feedback
• Innovation
• Ownership

Teams adapt to leaders’ emotional patterns. If a leader becomes sharp under pressure, people protect themselves. If a leader withdraws, ambiguity grows. If a leader tightens control, initiative shrinks.

Conversely, regulated leaders:

• Hold standards clearly
• Deliver feedback without escalation
• Separate behavior from identity
• Reinforce accountability without creating fear

This isn’t about being agreeable. It’s about being steady and consistent because steadiness builds resilient teams. 

Weekly Check In Practice

Self-regulation strengthens through self-reflection, repetition and commitment.

At the end of each week, ask:

• When did I feel triggered?
• How did I respond?
• What emotional wake did I leave?
• What would I repeat?
• What would I adjust?

Leadership growth does not come from insight alone; it comes developing awareness and disciplined action.

The Real Test of Leadership Maturity

Anyone can appear composed when things are calm and leadership maturity reveals itself when:

• You are challenged publicly
• A project derails
• A team member underperforms
• Pressure is high and timelines are tight

That is when culture is shaped and that is when your internal discipline becomes visible to others.

Emotional literacy allows you to recognize what you are feeling, and self-regulation allows you to choose how you respond.

Together, they determine whether your leadership builds trust or quietly diminishes it.

Final Thought on Emotional Literacy

We were never formally taught how to manage our internal world. Yet we are responsible for shaping the external environment of our teams.

Emotional literacy and self-regulation are not optional leadership traits. They are performance multipliers.

The goal is not to eliminate emotion. It is about effectively leading through it.

Let’s keep the conversation going. Reach out at 416-560-1806 or joanne.trotta@leadersedgeinc.ca. I’d love to hear your thoughts on this topic.

‍